Autism and specific language impairment sli are developmental disorders that, although distinct by definition, have in common some features of both language and social behavior. Differential diagnosis in psychosis and autism abigail donovan, md director, first episode and early psychosis program associate director, acute psychiatry service. The autism spectrum disorderdecision tree asddt is a decision tool developed to assist clinicians and researchers when screening for autism spectrum disorder asd and making diagnostic and assessment decisions. Case report differential diagnosis of autism spectrum. Accurate differential diagnosis should start with a deter. Autism spectrum disorders part 2 diagnosis and treatment diagnosis differential diagnosis diagnosing asd is no easy task, particularly since asd may mimic other disorders, and vice versa. Pdf differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder.
Although in the past this syndrome was commonly considered a separate diagnosis, it is now subsumed. Differential diagnosis between obsessive compulsive disorder and restrictive and repetitive behavioural patterns, activities and interests in autism spectrum disorders. Intellectual disability and autism spectrum disorder frequently cooccur. Pdf autism spectrum disorder asd is a neurodevelopmental disorder, often presenting in early childhood with restricted and repetitive. Differential diagnosis between obsessive compulsive disorder and restrictive and repetitive behavioural patterns, activities and interests in autism spectrum. Differential diagnosis of adhdadd in children and adults research informed assessment by carrie jaffe, ph. Differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorders. There are many differences between a medical diagnosis and an educational determination, or school evaluation, of a disability. Cdcs autism and developmental disabilities monitoring addm network 2008 identification influences. Children who are deaf or hard of hearing who have been diagnosed with autism have failed to develop symbolic gestures at the same rate as their nonautistic deaf and hard of hearing peers. An investigation into the differential diagnosis of autism.
Obsessive compulsive disorder ocd the obsessive thoughts and repetitive actions seen in ocd can appear very similar to the ritualistic behaviors and motor stereotypes seen in asd. Participation and discussion are essential to a complete learning experience. Based on database searches, we found that the awareness about autism among lay and professional public is higher in singapore compared to malaysia. Diagnosis differential diagnosis some conditions may have symptoms similar to autism. Differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder.
This site is for information purposes only and is a starting point for readers to look into options that may fit or resonate. The gdg considered that identifying other conditions in the differential diagnosis of autism was an essential element of the autism specific diagnostic assessment the benefit is the accurate and early recognition of alternative conditions, leading to earlier appropriate management. Autism spectrum disorders missouri autism guidelines. Differential and etiologic diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder. However, the recognition and study of this clinical issue. This situation can be remedied by replacing symptom surveys with differential diagnosis, i. Overview diagnostic criteria for autism spectrum disorder asd. Summary comorbid autism spectrum disorder asd and other mental health conditions are common.
The benefit is the accurate and early recognition of alternative conditions, leading to earlier appropriate management. Autism, language disorder, and social pragmatic communication disorder. The diagnosis of asd is often made difficult by the preponderance of differential diagnoses that should be considered in an individual presenting with the cognitive and behavioral symptoms of asd. A systematic approach to the differential diagnosis of asd. Autism spectrum disorder beyond the basics anxiety disorders in children and adolescents. About the dsm and autism spectrum disorder diagnosis. Pdf differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder and. A causal analysis january 11, 2020 by editor in trueautism rowland d 2020 differential diagnosis of autism.
Intellectual disabilitynow, more stigmatized than asd. Assistant professor of pediatrics developmental and behavioral pediatrician child development and rehabilitation center institute on development and disability oregon health and science university. Pdf autism spectrum disorder and its differential diagnosis. Intellectual disability in children with autism spectrum. This situation can be remedied by replacing symptom.
The autism spectrum disorder decision tree asddt for. The coventry grid autism and differential diagnosis. The purpose of our study was to determine the degree to which core adhd and autistic symptoms overlap in and discriminate between children 216 years of age with autism and adhd. This is a broad category of differential diagnoses with variable symptomatology depending on the specific diagnosis. Symptoms consistent with a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder asd overlap significantly with a wide range of psychiatric conditions. Differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder and post. Mar 31, 2017 differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder. Children with adhd and autism have some similar features, complicating a differential diagnosis. Making an autism spectrum disorder diagnosis autism case training. Parents of both children provided informed consent. Some will be on the autism spectrum and some will not, their difficulties being explained bu attachment problems. Kampbecker i 2011 differential diagnosis of autism.
Pdf autism spectrum disorder asd is estimated to affect one in 68 children. The coventry grid autism and differential diagnosis john. This paper raises the issue of differential diagnosis in children who present with social, emotional and behavioural difficulties. Children with autism have difficulty with symbolic gesture. Last year, a new classification of autism in the latest edition of the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders dsm5 attracted. Pervasive developmental disorders are now commonly referred to as autism spectrum disorders. Autism spectrum disorder asd is a biologically based neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by persistent deficits in social communication and social interaction and restricted, repetitive patterns of behavior, interests, and activities. Pda and differential diagnosis dr judy eaton consultant clinical psychologist. The goal of this study was to further explore the extent to which specific clinical features of autism are seen in sli. Differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder across. Autism spectrum disorder asd manifests in early childhood and is characterized by qualitative abnormalities in social interactions, markedly aberrant communication skills, and restricted repetitive behaviors, interests, and activities rrbs.
Differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder across the. Given the increase in both prevalence and awareness of asd. Autism canada does not endorse treatments, interventions and therapies but lists them so people can make informed choice. The other four disorders are asperger syndrome also called aspergers, aspergers syndrome, or aspergers disorder. Having certain autistic traits is not the same as autism. Autism now includes a spectrum of conditions of uncertain similarity because professionals are diagnosing by ticking off symptoms on a checklist. The gdg considered that identifying other conditions in the differential diagnosis of autism was an essential element of the autismspecific diagnostic assessment. Early diagnosis can make a huge difference in the lives of children with autism spectrum disorder and their families but its not always easy to make an asd diagnosis. Differential diagnosis in psychosis and autism abigail donovan, md director, first episode and early psychosis program associate director, acute psychiatry service massachusetts general hospital assistant professor of psychiatry harvard medical school.
The gdg considered that identifying other conditions in the differential diagnosis of autism was an essential element of the autism specific diagnostic assessment. And the challenge of communicating these alternative diagnoses in this era of autism awareness. It is considered by some authors to be simply a milder version of autistic. Feb, 2018 asperger syndrome also referred to as asperger disorder is a term applied to a form of autism spectrum disorder asd characterized by persistent impairment in social interactions and by repetitive behavior patterns and restricted interests.
Autism and intellectual disability may have common genetic components. An investigation into the differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder and attachment difficulties by rowan kendalljones a thesis submitted to the university of birmingham for the degree of doctor of. Missouri best practice guidelines for screening, diagnosis, and assessment is the result of a privatepublic partnership formed by the thompson foundation for autism and the division of developmental disabilities, missouri department of mental health. Autism spectrum disorder asd is estimated to affect one in 68 children. Asperger syndrome also referred to as asperger disorder is a term applied to a form of autism spectrum disorder asd characterized by persistent impairment in social interactions and by repetitive behavior patterns and restricted interests.
Mar 18, 2020 autism spectrum disorder asd manifests in early childhood and is characterized by qualitative abnormalities in social interactions, markedly aberrant communication skills, and restricted repetitive behaviors, interests, and activities rrbs. Pdf differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder and post. Goyert h, heinzelgutenbrunner m, kampbecker i 2011 differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder by means of inhibitory control and theory of. Here is a look at the practical aspects of what is involved in the diagnostic process, what to expect and how to ensure that you are receiving the best assessments possible and from the right professionals. Given the increase in both prevalence and awareness of asd, it is critical to provide accurate and timely diagnosis. Clinical practice guidelines for diagnosis of autism spectrum. Pda and differential diagnosis national autistic society. How autism spectrum disorder asd, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder adhd and anxiety disorders can be confused with each other diagnostically the processes by which these disorders can be disentangled from each other the approach to treating these disorders when they cooccur. Differential diagnosis of autism spectrum disorders or, refining autism awareness randall phelps, m. Diagnostic criteria dsm 5 currently, or by history, must meet criteria a, b, c, and d. Differential diagnosis of adhdadd in children and adults.
Differential diagnosis autism pubmed health national. Overlap between autism and specific language impairment. Other medical conditions or syndromes, such as sensory processing disorder, can present symptoms that are confusingly similar to autisms. Current research is investigating the specific symbolic gestures that are difficult. Hence, what is required of practitioners is making a differential diagnosis, or differentiating between conditions that share symptoms. Following is a list of related syndromesdisorders that manifest behaviors similar to those of autism andor are more prevalent in individuals with autism.
It is extremely different to make a differential diagnosis especially in asd children with severe intellectual disability. Individuals with a wellestablished dsmiv diagnosis of autistic disorder, aspergers disorder. Adhd is a neurobehavioral disorder that usually appears in early childhood before the age of 7. Differential diagnosis asd symptoms asd preschool symptoms asd schoolage syndromes associated with asd asd diagnosis tools related topics. When diagnosing autism spectrum disorder asd, professionals like paediatricians, psychiatrists, psychologists and speech pathologists use the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 5th edition, or dsm5, produced by the american psychiatric association. Study suggests imaging of neural representations of social interactions can iden. Pdf autism, language disorder, and social pragmatic. Several factors complicate the diagnosis of as an autism spectrum disorder. The assessment and diagnosis of autism is complex and so are the emotions and issues that arise with it. The asddt was developed to work in tandem with the pdd behavior inventory pddbi to improve diagnosis, document change. The special education system and approach towards autism treatment is also. Part of a library of materials written or collated by john whitwell. Diagnostic criteria for autism under the dsm5 as new research findings gradually lead us to a better understanding of autism, the criteria for a diagnosis of autism must continuously be revised. The goal of the current case study is to provide two illustrative examples of differential diagnosis in asd and ptsd observed in an autism clinic.
60 731 1566 1238 1337 135 1352 1588 563 647 1490 855 1085 782 1285 1366 351 965 189 1596 852 789 219 1378 565 357 1198 457 201 1033 121 430 1328 1006 1103 426